What does a C4 sugar test on honey catch, and what does it miss?

The C4 test catches added corn and cane sugar from roughly 7 per cent upwards. It cannot see rice, wheat or beet syrup, so a pass does not mean the honey is syrup-free.

A C4 sugar test checks, through the carbon isotope ratio, whether sugar from corn or sugar cane has been added to honey. The method compares the δ13C value of the honey with that of the protein extracted from it; under the Turkish Food Codex Communiqué on Honey, the calculated C4 sugar share may be no more than 7%. The test cannot see syrups made from rice, wheat or sugar beet, and it cannot separate additions below 7% from natural variation. A compliant C4 result therefore does not mean "no syrup"; it only shows that no measurable amount of C4-derived sugar was found.

What does the C4 test measure?

Plants fix carbon through different photosynthetic pathways. Most of the plants bees collect nectar from use the C3 pathway. Corn and sugar cane are C4 plants, and sugar made from them carries a higher share of 13C, the heavy carbon isotope. That ratio is expressed as the δ13C value, in parts per thousand (‰). When C4-derived sugar is added to honey, the honey's δ13C value shifts towards the less negative side.

The honey's own δ13C value is not enough on its own, because it varies with floral source and region. AOAC 998.12, the method laboratories commonly use, solves this by using the protein extracted from the same honey as an internal standard. Protein is not affected by sugar added to the honey afterwards. The wider the gap between the honey and its protein, the more likely it is that C4-derived sugar has entered the honey from outside. The method calculates the C4 sugar share as a percentage from this gap; a negative result is reported as 0%.

What limits does the Communiqué on Honey set for C4?

Annex 1 of the Communiqué on Honey (No. 2020/7) has three rows for isotope analysis:

CriterionBlossom honeyHoneydew honeyBlend of blossom and honeydew honeyBaker's honey
Honey δ13C value-23 or more negative-23 or more negative; -22.5 or more negative for pine honey-23 or more negativeNo value given
Difference between protein and honey δ13C-1.0 or more positive-1.0 or more positive; not required for pine honey-1.0 or more positive-1.0 or more positive
C4 sugar share (maximum)7%7%; not required for pine honey7%7%

In practice, the difference row means the honey's δ13C value must not have shifted more than 1‰ to the positive side of its own protein's value. We cover the pine honey exceptions separately in our post on pine honey analysis.

The Communiqué states that internationally recognised methods of analysis are to be applied. A 2023 amendment (No. 2023/37) added "decision criteria" (karar ölçütü): when establishing whether a substance has been added to honey, the decision criteria of the analytical methods announced on the Ministry of Agriculture and Forestry's website are also used. An announced criterion starts to apply in official controls three months after its publication. Which criteria have been announced should be followed on the Ministry's website.

Which syrups can the C4 test not see?

Rice, wheat and sugar beet are C3 plants. Syrups made from them have an isotope ratio close to that of nectar sugar, and the C4 test cannot tell them apart.

In its 2021-2022 "From the Hives" action on honey imported into the EU, the European Commission flagged 147 of 320 samples (46%) as suspected of non-compliance. The Commission wrote that the EA-IRMS isotope method, which its page refers to as AOAC 991.41, was not effective in detecting the suspect honeys, and explained this by corn and cane syrups having possibly been replaced, totally or partially, by syrups made from rice, wheat or sugar beet.

A study from Türkiye showed the same limit from the angle of bee feeding. In work by researchers at Ondokuz Mayıs University, published in Food Chemistry in 2014, colonies were fed different amounts of commercial syrups. The official isotope methods could not efficiently identify honey from colonies fed syrups made from C3 plants, and at the lowest feeding level (5 litres per colony) adulteration could not be detected by the AOAC criteria for any sugar type.

Why is "below 7 per cent" not the same as clean?

The 7% threshold is a detection limit, not a permitted level of addition. The isotope spread among natural honeys does not allow additions below that level to be distinguished. Other known limits of the method:

  • Differences between laboratories. A ten-laboratory comparison published in the Journal of AOAC International in 2013 noted that, for a honey with a C4 result between 3% and 7%, measurement differences between laboratories raise the risk that honey passing in the exporting country fails a second test in the importing country.
  • Negative values reported as 0%. The same study warned that honeys with naturally negative C4 values could be blended with syrup-adulterated honey to bring the result under the 7% threshold.
  • False positives. When protein is extracted, pollen and other insoluble matter can precipitate with it and shift the protein value. This led to false positives in New Zealand manuka honey. A similar tendency was reported for pine honey in 2022: most genuine pine honey samples failed AOAC 998.12, and most were classified as authentic once the protein was cleaned up by ultrafiltration.

Which methods replace or complement C4?

Liquid chromatography-isotope ratio mass spectrometry (LC-IRMS), which measures the isotope ratio of each sugar in honey separately rather than a single δ13C value, has been published as European standard EN 17958:2024. The standard determines the δ13C value of fructose, glucose, di- and trisaccharides; the results are compared with guidance values for genuine honey. Compliance assessment is outside the standard's scope.

In "From the Hives", the Commission's Joint Research Centre (JRC) also looked for syrup markers by high-resolution mass spectrometry alongside isotope analysis. A methodological review prepared by the Authenticity Methodology Working Group (AMWG) and published by the UK Department for Environment, Food & Rural Affairs (Defra) on 13 February 2025 named EA/LC-IRMS as the most important test to apply and said a finding of sugar addition by that test should not be dismissed. The same review recommended reporting outcomes as "flag for further investigation", and noted that syrup levels below 5-10% are unlikely to come from economically motivated adulteration and that over-interpretation should be avoided.

How do you read a C4 lab report?

  1. Check the method. The report should state which method was used (for example AOAC 998.12) and whether the analysis falls within the laboratory's accreditation scope.
  2. Read the four values together. Honey δ13C, protein δ13C, the difference between them and the calculated C4 share. A report that gives only the C4 percentage does not show where the result came from.
  3. Match the honey type to the right column. If pine honey is assessed against the blossom honey column, the result is misread. The honey type should be written on the request form when the sample is sent.
  4. Read 0% correctly. 0% says no C4-derived sugar was measurable. It says nothing about C3 syrups.
  5. Ask for a repeat near the limits. The 3-7% range is where differences between laboratories can change the decision. For non-compliant honeys with high pollen content or honeydew origin, discuss the protein preparation step with the laboratory.
  6. Widen the methods if needed. If doubt remains, the sugar profile, LC-IRMS, or methods such as mass spectrometry and NMR add information.

This table does not replace the HMF, moisture and diastase rows, which we cover in our post on HMF, moisture and diastase.

Where does Beevex fit in this sequence?

C4 and other isotope analyses are done in a laboratory. Beevex does not measure δ13C, nor floral source. It is a screening step used at intake or filling: five drops taken from the jar go into the kit's test dish, the mobile app gives the result as genuine, questionable or syrup added, and the result is recorded with the batch details. A questionable batch is set aside for laboratory confirmation. Beevex does not replace laboratory analysis; it helps decide which batch goes to the laboratory. You can find the staged acceptance decision in our post on honey buying and the method on the technology page.

Frequently asked questions

Is honey that passes the C4 test genuine? That cannot be said with certainty. The result only shows that sugar from corn and sugar cane stayed below the 7% threshold. Honey with added rice, wheat or beet syrup can pass this test.

Does honey with a 5% C4 result comply with the Communiqué? It complies on the C4 row, since the limit is a maximum of 7%. The other rows of the report and the other Annex 1 criteria are assessed separately. This is not legal advice; the current text of the Communiqué and the Ministry's announcements apply.

Is a C4 test done on pine honey? The Communiqué does not require the C4 share or the protein-honey difference for pine honey; it only sets a limit of -22.5 or more negative for the honey δ13C value. Details are in our post on pine honey.

Does feeding bees syrup show up in a C4 test? Not always. In the 2014 study, honey from colonies fed C3-derived syrups could not be efficiently identified by the official isotope methods, and at a low feeding level C4-derived syrup could not be detected either.

What does "AOAC 998.12" on the report mean? It is the AOAC International official method that compares the carbon isotope ratio of honey with that of the protein extracted from it. It targets C4 plant sugars.

Sources

Meeting request

Let us plan the setup together, starting from your intake processes and existing controls.

The first meeting reviews your product, sales channels and the risks you face, and recommends a suitable method.

Request a meeting